I work with a wide range of clients in studio and via distance with my coaching program. In my opinion, one of the first things a trainer must get comfortable with is learning to work WITH a client’s limitations in order to safely net them results. I realized that I have never written about this, and the topic has been on my mind with some recent work I have done.
Are you a trainer? If so this maybe useful to you.
Do you fit in to one of these special population categories? If so, I believe this will be helpful to your progress.
As I enjoy starting with questions, here is the start:
- Do you currently subscribe to a belief system which states every person needs basically the same workout, and all that is required is a scaling of poundage or reps?
- Do you currently believe “all they need” is your blend of guru approved exercises pet to your favorite training system?
- Is your training program centered on a certain exercise tool/piece of equipment, a certain rep scheme, an ideologically focused movement pattern, or an ideal state selected end goal?
If you answer “Yes” to any of these three questions, I know one thing is certain. You are going to plateau. Your gains will be slow. If you are a trainer you likely have hurt someone, probably yourself.
Is there another way to get the job done?
Special Populations
There are many groupings of people we could title special populations. A simple way I define it is a group of people who have common needs or restrictions which alter their training program significantly.
Obese
First lets be clear here. Obese is not the same as “over-weight.” Obese refers specifically to BODY FAT percentage or body mass index (BMI) exceeding a set value . While tt is possible to be “over-weight” and be lean it is also rare. Body builders and many professional athletes are an example of being over weight while lean. Men who lift weights with beer bellies are not.
If you are involved in the fitness industry then you are tied to obesity and fat loss to some degree.
Here is an opinion, personal trainers are the first line of offense in the war on flab.
America is the fattest country in the world, by percentage and by population. To be more specific, we have the most obese people, the most over weight people. We have the most over weight kids, adults, and seniors.
We are fucking fat.
I am looking at a chart right now published by the US FDA which lists men with a body fat percentage 25%> and women 30%> as obese. I have a similar chart from the University of Minnesota exercise science department. The national heart and lung association lists a BMI of over 30 as obese.
Men, if you are over 25% body fat you are classified as obese. If your BMI is over 30 you are obese. Yes you are.
Now a lot of people say things such as “everyone I know is over 25%” or “BMI is bullshit, everyone I know is over 30″
That does not mean they are not obese, it just means everyone you know is dangerously fat.
It is true most men in this sad country are now over 25%.
Body mass index is often criticized are being “completely worthless” but I strongly disagree.
here is a BMI calculator. Click on it and insert your numbers.
What did you find?
I am 6′ 2″ tall, I weigh 212 lbs at a body fat of 11.5%. My body mass index is 27.2.
If I get my weight to 220, my BMI goes up to 28.2. If my body weight was 230 it would 29.5. If my body weight was 234 it would be a 30.
I carry 191 lbs of fat free mass right now. The only way for me to get to 234 would be to add a lot of fat. In the next decade of training it is unlikely I will push my fat free mass over 215. Lean mass simply happens VERY SLOW. So for most people these rapid gains in weight are from BODY FAT. Don’t take my word for it, get out your tape measure and calipers and learn for yourself.
30 or greater BMI = obese holds true with EVERY drug free athlete I personally know. I was playing with the calculator as I wrote this and ran the stats of every person I know. Guess what- the only people who went over BMI 30 were the ones who are also carrying too much fat. Check for yourself.
Check for yourself.
Back on target….
What is the problem here with training obese people?
For my readers who have never carried over 15-20% BF I have an educational experiment for you to run. You will need an X vest or backpack. I would like you to put on 50lbs and wear it ALL DAY from dawn to dusk. In fact to reap full benefits I want you to wear this for TWO FULL DAYS, from the second you wake up to the minute you are back in bed.
You will quickly find out, everything that was easy is now harder. You are tired fast. Your joints may hurt. You may find yourself out of breath, sweating, beat down, from routine activity.
I bring this up because I am not impressed with the lack of compassion many trainers have with very fat people. What is a trainers job again? I thought it was to make the client better. I didn’t realize it was a trainers job to punish other people for not living a bitching ass rock star life of total fitness.
I don’t want to deflect in to a rant on “Biggest Loser” so I will leave it at this- do not abuse people.
I will examine solutions below.
Senior citizens
I often hear people use the expression “golden years” to describe elderly people, I don’t know where the gold is. As far as I can observe getting old sucks.
Taking a broad view of problems associated with aging- cardio vascular risk, cardio pulmonary issues, a range of mobility restrictions, the life time of accumulated injury, typically a number of prescription medications (which you must at least have a primitive understanding of) bone softening/weakness, decreased energy, decreased coordination, and reduced recovery time.
More elderly Americans are hitting the gym now than ever before (winning!) and which this comes a population base which did not grow up learning fitness to the extent of our 18-40 year old population now. This means a lot of people are stepping in the door who have truly no idea what to do. They are looking for people to teach them to safely train their body. I suppose everyone else is too, but I mention this in particular to an important concern of mine. Injury.
If your 20 year old kid pulls hammie training with you tonight, he will likely be in tomorrow. He may bitch about his leg hurting, but you will train around it. Likely our young stud will be feeling good in 5-8 days and fully recovered in 2 weeks.
A brand new client age 70 may be bed ridden for a month from a mild training accident. Additionally the injury may scare her so badly that every belief she has about fitness being dangerous is cemented even further.
The flip side of this is simple: do not baby them or treat them like kids which is a disturbing trend I have witnessed. Your senior citizen client is not stupid, do not treat them as such. You know who you are.
The mangled
Life is fucking hard and dangerous. No one makes it out alive in the long run, and there are a lot of people who have the scars to prove it.
The mangled is the collection of all the people who can tell you first hand that shit happens. These people often suffer restrictions in various movements, and will not always fit in to your model of perfect form. That is unless you are smart enough to understand THERE IS NO PERFECT FORM. See my article series on form here Part I, Part II, Part III. Read the fucking articles too, don’t just pass them over.
People don’t like being told what they have to do, and they often don’t like being told what they can’t do. Your job is not to make them do anything, or stop them from trying. Your job is to make them better. Keep that in mind, especially my homies in the corrective exercise fields.
Keep this in mind- just because something could be “corrected” does not mean it is time to address it.
Kids
More parents are turning over their kids to trainers and coaches these days. I think that is great. Start them young. Unless of course you are starting them off on your broken view of the body and the world.
Here are some important things you need to know.
Kids are not able to explain themselves so well. Neither are most adults. Kids typically have a short attention span. Then again so do most adults.
I am lost for a moment here, because the most important points about kids seem to be universal as I reflect…
Ok, here are my opinions.
Kids exercise is more like a guided play time than a PT appointment. I’ll ask a kid what they want to do, I ask them if they want to do it now. “Do you want to climb the rope, jump on the boxes, catch the ball, or lift that weight?” The right answer is whatever comes out their mouth.
Kids do not need to be pushed. They just need to be pointed. If you find your kid doesn’t like the options you are offering, I say the packaging or marketing sucks.
Find ways to make things like a game.
“Hey buddy how many times do you think you could jump on this box in 30 seconds?” “Think you can do it again and beat that number?”
What does it take to work with a kid? The same thing it takes to work with a dog. Control the situation, keep things in relative order, keep them safe, make the time spent productive. I do not see it as my job to teach the kid life lessons, enforce discipline, or be any kind of role model. That job falls to their parents.
My job is to help your little booger picker get better at their sport, at moving, or lose their junior pot belly.
So what do you need to do?
Don’t pretend your a fucking doctor. They need to see a doctor before they work with you. It’s for you, it’s for them.
Do keep track of medical requirements/limitations of the client.
Work within their limits.
Ask more questions
Stop assuming, stop knowing, get thinking.
A three step process- Ask them what the problem is, design experiments to find answers to the problem, execute best solution located from the experiment.
See how easy that is? Imagine if you learned to stop telling people what they need to do and started asking them what they want to do? Wow, it’s like you would be a totally more useful trainer!
Scale movements, do not eliminate them. If your current understanding of movement prevents you from finding safe and appropriate movement than you need to turn the client over to someone who is responsible enough to know what they are doing.
Know what a kettlebell swing is? Hip flexion/hip extension, with knee flexion/knee extension, and a minor degree of spinal extension. Know how small the ROM can be? 6 inches, even less I suppose. Just hinge and stand up. Not what you were told by your favorite trainer at your course? Ge hip to life homie. Do what the client can do, do not force them.
Be aware of high impact and high speed movements.
Best of all- lead with testing. Test everything. Leave it all to their body to decide.
For those who will do this, better results are in the cards.
In my upcoming Smarter Strength Workshop I will be covering strategies for working with a variety of people, and how to get them results no matter what their starting point is.
{ 13 comments }
The dots are way too far apart on this one, homey.
No they’re not.
Starting with the lose your gut, and perfect form posts, I hope these subjects and styles are going to be continual trends in your writing. Fucking awesome post.
word. another good one.
Just my two cents here. At just a hair under 6 feet, according to the calculator to be at a “normal” BMI, my weight could fluctuate between 135 and 182. While I don’t disagree that my current weight of 186 could be a bit trimmer, I would look like an alien at 135. My wife would probably divorce me also.
Dustin I don’t know what you are talking about. 6’0 @ 182 puts you at 24.7 = Normal. Even up to 200, which if you are 6’0 200 and <10% BF you are fucking shredded, puts the BMI at 27.1 which is well below the 30 threshold we are talking about here.
If you are 6’0, 200lbs, and less than 12% body fat, you should expect to be off a whole lot of charts because you will look like fucking wolverine.
Dave, I wasn’t questioning the scale on the upside, but rather the downside. It seems like they need to tighten up the ” normal” range to me. And yes, I would like to look like wolverine.
Bloody great post! Keep up your amazing work
/Martin, Sweden
good shit!
great stuff Adam, this will certainly give me some stuff to consider as a trainer.
I can’t believe how hard the idea of TEST IT FOR YOURSELF is to sell to people. It is just absurdly simple: do something, record what happens, think about it, move on.
This applies to everything of course, but training is an obvious (and fruitful) application. It’s time people stopped thinking there was “a correct answer” and started looking critically at their behavior and its results.
Reading through this site, you continually urge people to TEST IT FOR YOURSELF, but it seems to me that it takes a scarily long time for people to actually try it.
Why? Could it be the tendency of the ego to protect itself?
It appears to me that the personality acts mostly to protect itself from loss of self-esteem. Critical examination of one’s own behavior represents a threat to the safety of our self-evaluation (and sometimes our livelihood, in the case of some in the fitness industry).
That does not, however, mean that their ideas work. In my experience, it generally means the opposite.
I’m curious as to your thoughts on this.
Great stuff Adam!
I love this part
“Keep this in mind- just because something could be “corrected” does not mean it is time to address ”
So true!
And as a formerly mangled person (everyone has issues), if I would have learned sooner to test things instead of adding more tension to do “proper form” I would have saved myself a lot of pain and lost time. Word to the wise kiddies.
I go agree with your general point of BMI, but at an individual level it is very crude at best. Measurements and pictures are better.
Great stuff on kids. I teach Child Fitness and the first question I had before I agreed to teach it was what I was going to teach, since much of the info out there is horrible. Add to this some crazy parents and no wonder our kids who are trying to get better are not!
Rock on
Mike T Nelson PhD(c)
I’m still not on board with BMI.
BMI tells fat sedentary people what they already know: They are fat.
BMI is clearly misleading to many athletes.
Just three recent examples from my little world:
The guy that runs the crossfit box I’m based out of is 6’3″, 104kg and is 29 on the BMI. He’s one of the top 10 crossfitters in our region and is very lean looking.
My best junior oly weightlifter is 5’8″ and walks around at about 87kg. The first impression you have of this kid is how ripped he is. His BMI is 29.2, overweight and just a tad under registering obese.
I have another senior 85kg lifter that walls around at around 90kg (moving up to 94s) at 5’9 his BMI is 29.2. Eating is almost a full time job for him and he is also noticeabley lean.
Prefer a Tanita scale (with all its faults) for a relative body comp read over time over the BMI anyday.
R
Awesome post, Adam! This is particularly interesting and useful to me because I’m am doing what I can to help me two little brothers and my aging mother to rebuild their bodies and improve their day-to-day lives. Much thanks; you still run the #1 site I read/study!